Public Health Agency of Canada
Symbol of the Government of Canada

Share this page

Population Health in Canada: A Working Paper

IV. Snapshot: Adoption of a Population Health Approach

This section provides the descriptive snapshot of population health research and ideas used in public policy in Canada. We view the task of policy-makers and program planners dedicated to implementing population health activities as four-fold:

  1. first, to assimilate lessons from population health research;

  2. second, to identify relevant determinants of health within their jurisdictions and opportunities for collaboration across sectors of government and society;

  3. third, to enact policies and programs directed toward affecting the determinants in the desired direction; and

  4. fourth, to assess the health and social impact(s) of their policy and program choices by conducting evaluation exercises in support of accountability.

Healthy public policies and programs can be instituted at the federal, provincial, regional and local levels of government. The governmental division can be explicitly health-related or not, or it may involve collaboration among divisions. Population health initiatives can provide impetus and support for health and social impact assessments. In turn, assessment of the health, social, economic and environmental impact of program and policies (within and across sectors) can contribute to advancing the population health agenda. Stakeholders from diverse sectors of government and society will have important perspectives on, and contributions to, such assessments.

We have restricted our "snapshot" of population health to policy-related activities in Canada at the federal, provincial and regional levels. This was due to time and resource issues, but we welcome updates from conference participants with additional Canadian or international experiences. Appendix A lists the documents synthesized to create this snapshot and other key references.

In summarizing the available documents, we envision a rough gradient of commitment to and experience with a population health perspective among government institutions (and other sectors of society), and, as such, we differentiate between:

  • evidence of the adoption of a population health philosophy,

  • creation of new structures or organizations in support of shared responsibility for population health,

  • re-allocation of existing resources towards population health initiatives,

  • creation of new programs or policies supporting intersectoral action on population health,

  • development of new partnerships, and

  • collection of data (with evaluation mechanisms) in support of health and social impact assessments.

While the present snapshot pertains to policy-related, Canadian and government-located initiatives, we believe the levels of adoption/implementation identified above will be equally relevant to population health initiatives (program and policy) undertaken across different levels of government and sectors of society. New structures or partnerships will also logically engage key players from outside the health sector and from beyond government. Representatives of diverse jurisdictions may each bring their own values, beliefs and experiences regarding the objects of interest or foci for health and social impact assessments. Additionally, they may bring diverse perspectives as to the standards of acceptability and/or definitions of success for population health activities.

The "Canadian Population Health Initiative" provides an example of a partnership that brings together different levels of government and nongovernmental organizations (Health Canada, Statistics Canada, the Federal/Provincial/Territorial Advisory Committee on Population Health, and the Canadian Institute for Health Information). It will create new knowledge and enhance Canadian's understanding about health, its determinants, and the performance of the health system, and identify policy directions for improved health and well-being of Canadians.

Snapshot of Adoption & Implementation of Population Health in Canada

Adoption of Population Health Philosophy

Jurisdiction

Document Source

A population health approach has been adopted by Health Canada, and the Health Promotion and Programs Branch (HPPB), in particular, as a guiding principle in its major areas of activity; including risk management, aboriginal health, health promotion and disease prevention, and health system support and renewal. "HPPB will play a key role in this broader effort through its leadership in promoting the population health approach and through its role in coordinating national population health strategies" (p.1).

Health Canada (national)

Health Canada (1998)

The direction of Newfoundland & Labrador's community health program is guided by "a population health promotion approach, which focuses on factors that enhance the health and well-being of the overall population, [and] is advocated for all core programs" (p.10).

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1997)

The Strategic Social Plan for Newfoundland and Labrador represents "an overall framework" (p.3) with innovative measures aimed at meaningful change; one of its goal is to foster "collective well-being" (p.iii). It will shift the Government's approach from crisis-driven remedial programs toward proactive approaches that stress the well-being of the whole population. Although the term 'population health' is used, phrases such as 'well-being' are used more frequently to convey the Government's change in philosophy. It states: "Specific emphasis will be placed on the links between social and economic development, on population health and well-being and on economic security" (p.17). Furthermore, the Government recognizes that "an investment in prevention requires more upfront spending" (p.11).

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1998)

"It is no coincidence that the Ontario Public Health Association has declared that a determinants of health perspective will shape all of its policy recommendations." In its report, Determinants of Health September 1992 - December 1993, the OPHA states that "education policy is health policy; tax policy is health policy; employment policy is health policy."

ON

Foley (1994)

The population health goals of Saskatchewan "focus on health of the population as a whole, rather than the health of the individual. Working groups have been established to develop measurable objectives for each goal and to identify specific population health initiatives to meet each objective" (p.12).

SK

Health Canada. Pop. Health From Rhetoric to Action

Since 1994 in British Columbia, the Annual Reports of the Provincial Health Officer have been based on a determinants of health framework. Similarly, the Health Goals of British Columbia, recently adopted by the province, reflect a population health perspective. Support during the development of the health goals, which contain objectives for each goal, included Cabinet endorsement, input and commitment from ministry stakeholders, other ministries and regional authorities.

BC

Peck (1999

Closer to Home makes reference to the broader influences upon health that lie outside the health care system.

BC

Hayes & Dunn (1998)

 

Snapshot of Adoption & Implementation of Population Health in Canada

Creation of New Structures or Organizations (Shared Responsibility)

Jurisdiction

Document Source

The North West Territories have created a number of community service boards, amalgamated the Departments of Health and Social Services, and created new Health Intelligence and Health and Wellness units within the Department of Health. These units have been given broad mandates which are expected to contribute to broader political and public awareness of health determinants.

NWT

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

"In the Northwest Territories, a group of deputy ministers has pooled their resources to form a social-economic 'think tank,' called the Social Envelope Committee, to address issues of healthy public policy. In addition, a Deputy Minister's Interdepartmental Steering Committee on Community Wellness and regional interdepartmental committees were established to further develop the community wellness strategy" (p.64).

NWT

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

In July 1996, the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador appointed a Social Policy Advisory Committee of fourteen volunteers from various regions and backgrounds which developed the Province's strategic social plan. A Council on Social Development is planned which will provide advice on provincial directions with specific emphasis on the links between social and economic development, population health and well-being, and economic security.

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1998)

Newfoundland deliberately separated community service boards from institutional service boards to ensure the former's engagement with population health ideas. A key informant states: "we wanted CHBs to have the same status and clout as the institutional boards, without all of the budgetary distractions of institutional services"(p.50).

NF & Labrador

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

In most provinces, a variety of positions have been created by regional /community health boards to engage in a population health approach. For example, coordinators from outside the traditional health system with backgrounds in community development and co-op housing have been hired (NS), a position dedicated to community liaison around determinants of health (PEI), positions in community development have been approved (NF), new positions in population health policy research (SK).

NF NS PEI & SK

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

The Calgary Regional Health Authority, "despite being in a deficit position, ...has created a new population health division with a mandate to 'reduce inequities in health status'" (p.35).

Calgary, AB (regional)

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

The Vancouver-Richmond Health Board has created population health advisory committees for the following groups: aboriginal peoples; children and youth; lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender; mental health; multicultural; people with disabilities; seniors; and women.

Vancouver/ Richmond, BC (regional)

Vancouver/Richmond Health Board (1999)

In British Columbia, the Office of the Provincial Health Officer was established to report annually on the health of British Columbians as measured against population health targets.

BC

Gov't of BC (1996

 

Snapshot of Adoption & Implementation of Population Health in Canada

Re-allocation of Existing Resources

Jurisdiction

Document Source

To support a population health approach, Health Canada has created a Population Health Fund "designed to support time-limited projects sponsored by voluntary, non-profit, non-governmental organizations which contribute to an increased capacity for action on the determinants of population health... Projects may be local, regional or national in scope..." (p.1-3).

National

Health Canada (1997)

Funding of federal health research on population health

National

NHRDP (1998)

An annual $4 million Community Action, which supports a range of population health initiatives, such as healthy community and mental health projects, family violence prevention, training for caregivers and early intervention services for children and families, is disbursed through regional boards. It requires "co-investment" from communities which is assessed according to their abilities.

NWT

Informant, as cited in Labonte, et al.(1998)

"The Yukon may be unique in writing into its legislation a requirement that, by the year 2000, an equivalent 5% of the treatment budget must be allocated for health promotion" (p.31). Although the term 'population health' is not used ('quality of life' is preferred), issues around the determinants of health are part of the government's agenda.

Yukon

Labonte Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

The Government of Newfoundland & Labrador recognizes that "an investment in prevention requires more upfront spending" (p.11). Accordingly, the Government is "allocating additional resources to family resource programs, child care services (including infant care) and services for youth which will improve the range of available early stage intervention programs" (p.23).

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1998)

In Saskatchewan, both Health Promotion and Wellness Grants have health determinants as part of their criteria. The 1997/98 Provincial Wellness Grants specifically targets income and social status, social support networks, employment and working conditions and physical environments" (p.39). Since 1994, almost $100 million has been allocated for rural health initiatives, including population health, health promotion and disease prevention programs.

SK

Labonte Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

In British Columbia and Saskatchewan, regional health authorities have authority to transfer funds from allocations for institutional health care to community-care or health promotion and prevention programs, but cannot move funds in the reverse direction (p.33,38).

BC & SK

Labonte Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

"The Vancouver-Richmond Board...developed a $5 million grants program, $750,000 of which went to health promotion and disease prevention projects and another $750,000 reserved for projects that specifically address poverty, literacy and housing. The remainder of the grants program went to initiatives in mental health, aboriginal health, plans for development of community health centres and home care.... The money for the grants program came from reallocations from the service sector" (p.34)

Vancouver-Richmond, BC (regional)

Informant, as cited in Labonte Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

"In 1993, the British Columbia Health Research Foundation dedicated one of its operational grant funding envelopes to population health research" (p.1).

BC

Hayes & Dunn (1998)

 

Snapshot of Adoption & Implementation of Population Health in Canada

Creation of New Programs or Policies (Shared Responsibility)

Jurisdiction

Document Source

The National Children's Agenda brings together health and social ministries across levels of government. The National Literacy Secretariat highlights the role of non-health factors as important determinants of health.

FPT Partnership

Health Canada, HRDC (1998)

A Health Canada sponsored workshop on Employment and Health held in Ottawa in 1996 situated 'employment and health' as a research and policy issue within the population health framework. While identifying policy implications and priorities for policy research it was noted that the CIAR population health framework needs to be enhanced both conceptually and empirically.

National

Hollander, Vol. I (1996)

Newfoundland having recognized that the challenges facing the Province "cannot be addressed simply by adjusting existing policies and programs," (p.8) recently adopted a Guide to Assess the Health Implications of Public Policy which "acts as a decision enhancement tool that allows for broader thinking on the determinants of health" (p.67). A "Policy Circle Team" involving all senior government policy makers are the primary users.

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1998)

BC has introduced a similar tool, a Health Impact Assessment, which recommended that all policies be considered for health impacts. In BC, the Population Health Resource Branch of the Ministry of Health assists other ministries in the use of the Health Impact Assessment tool (p.7).

BC

Informant, as cited in Labonte, et al. (1998); Health Canada (1998)

"Using a population health promotion approach, which focuses on the factors that influence health as well as incorporating health promotion and other strategies, the Core Programs document outlines specific goals, objectives, strategies, activities and indicators for four major core programs of Community Health. These include: promotion and support of health and well being; promotion of a healthy environment; prevention and control of communicable diseases; and provision of health services" (p.1)

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1998)

The British Columbia Health Goals has been incorporated into many policy documents, such as the Ministry of Health's Strategic Plan and Women's Health Planning Project, the Ministry of Children and Families' Performance Management Framework, the Provincial HIV/AIDS Framework for Action, and is used by the Inter-Ministry HIV/AIDS and Aboriginal HIV/AIDS Committees.

BC

Peck (1999)

In Vancouver's, community members and three levels of government are collaborating to address the HIV epidemic among drug users. They are exploring conditions such as poverty, lack of housing, social isolation, criminalization of drug addiction, lack of supported training/employment and lack of access to appropriate and integrated health and social services.

Vancouver- Richmond, BC (regional)

Health Canada (1998)

"The Vancouver-Richmond Board...purchased two rooming-house type hotels to provide secure social housing for a homeless population with mental health problems, or at high risk of HIV transmission through IV drug use.... It has committed another $3 million in this fiscal year units" (p.32).

Vancouver- Richmond, BC (regional)

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

 

Snapshot of Adoption & Implementation of Population Health in Canada

Development of New Partnerships (Shared Responsibility)

Jurisdiction

Document Source

The Health Promotion and Programs Branch (HPPB) business transformation is one of four major initiatives being spearheaded by Health Canada, collectively aimed at: connecting to the international community to position population health as the new vision for health in the next century; entrenching the population health approach in the broader federal agenda; developing a broader awareness of the population health approach to Canadians and communities; and changing the way HPPB does its work; by enhancing and adopting the Department's population health in all of its current and planned activities.

Health Canada (National)

Health Canada (1998)

To promote a population health approach in Canada, Health Canada lists some potential partners: First Nations; the health and social services system; Provincial Ministries of Health; universities, colleges and research centres; provincial, national and local voluntary organizations; other non-health sectors and government departments; the general population; the international 'community'; and the private sector.

Health Canada (National)

Health Canada (1998)

Five territorial departments (education, culture and employment; health and social services; justice; municipal and community affairs; NWT Housing Corporation) with representatives from Aboriginal organizations, women's groups, non-government organizations, and community and cultural groups, produced the report Working Together for Community Wellness which "proposes a new vision for healthier communities in the Northwest Territories" (p.14)

NWT

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

The implementation of Newfoundland and Labrador's Strategic Social Plan includes: the Social Policy Committee of Cabinet consisting of Ministers from 9 Ministries; interdepartmental partnerships; strategic partnerships with the Federal Government; and the community including the Premier's Council on Social Development and regional boards (health institution boards, health and community service boards, school boards, and economic development boards).

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1998)

An example of where a determinants of health approach is employed are the project alliances around homelessness and mental health being formed by some hospitals, CHCs, public health departments and other local service providers and community agencies.

ON

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

The Ontario Public Health Association workshops on the determinants of health was implemented with the assistance of an advisory committee made up of representatives from the following organizations: Association of District Health Councils, Association of Local Official Health Agencies, Association of Ontario Health Centres, Institute of Cultural Affairs, Ontario Public Health Association, Ontario Social Development Council, and the Premier's Council on Health, Well-being and Social Justice.

ON

Foley (1994)

The Vancouver-Richmond Health Board worked with a partnership of other government and private sectors, raising over $5 million for the purchase of two rooming-house type hotels in the downtown area (p.32)

Vancouver/ Richmond, BC (regional)

Labonte, Jackson, & Chirrey (1998)

 

Snapshot of Adoption & Implementation of Population Health in Canada

Data Collection / Evaluation Mechanisms
(Accountability & Impact Assessment)

Jurisdiction

Document Source

"Statistics Canada has invested in person-oriented longitudinal surveys, such as the National Population Health Survey..." (p.21).

Canada (National)

Mustard (1999)

The Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) "helps its many clients to make sound health decisions based on quality health information." John Millar (CIHI) asserts that a set of indicators to determine how well regional or provincial health care systems are functioning should include "major non-medical determinants of health.."

Offices in 4 Canadian cities (national implications)

www.cihi.ca

Five years following implementation of the Strategic Social Plan, Government will conduct a social audit which will indicate what is working, why, how and for whom. It will include: an assessment of the status of the population in three areas, general well-being, employment and economic security, and community stability; an analysis of particular groups, such as unemployed persons and seniors; and an assessment of the impact of major social programs and services.

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1998)

"Provincial and regional reports [of Community Health Core Programs] should be submitted to the Assistant Deputy Minister (Community) at the end of the fiscal year. Analysis and subsequent feedback will occur. Liaison with the Provincial office throughout the implementation process is encouraged" (p.104).

NF & Labrador

Government of NF & Labrador (1997)

Nova Scotia Trends: A Population Health Perspective profiles key trends in the social, economic, demographic and health status of Nova Scotians. It states: "documenting these changes is a necessary part of the process of understanding their implications.... As these factors change, so do their consequences for our health." It contains major sections on the changing population dynamics and health status of Nova Scotians, the availability of health services, the family, the economy and employment, and incomes and poverty. It incorporates data from over 20 sources.

NS

Pennock (1996)

POPULIS is a population health information system, developed by the Manitoba Centre for Health Policy and Evaluation "to help the public understand that more health care is not necessarily better and to help planners identify the levers for combining the concerns of population health and cost containment" (p.4). The system is able to create regional profiles, document anomalies, and facilitate the development of policy for improving population health.

MN (applicable elsewhere)

Roos, et al. (1996)

To monitor a population's overall health and well-being, key indicators are sometimes combined to create an aggregate measure. Examples of composite measures of health include the Health Status Index developed in Manitoba, and the Population Health Index being developed by Statistics Canada and the Canadian Institute for Health Information.

MN & Canada (applicable elsewhere)

BC. Provincial Health Officer's Annual Report (1996)


Table Of Contents